A Lobster Scream

We finished up Julie/Julia with a bang …. or a whimper if you count the sound the student made when she put the lobster in the pot for our dinner of Cheese Souffle, Lobster Thermidor and Floating Islands.
We had several students who “killed their first lobster”. Of course, the question invariably arises about the pain lobsters feel as they are being dropped into the pot of boiling water. I did some research and while the debate will probably rage for years to come, the majority of evidence suggests that lobsters simply aren’t intelligent enough nor developed enough to feel pain. Pain is a neurological event while suffering is an emotional event. Your emotional makeup indicates the degree to which you feel the suffering when you stick your foot into a too warm bath. Others might laugh and call you a sissy at the same temperature. Julia Child could stick her hand into a pot of boiling water to grab a piece of pasta. Not me!! My tolerance to suffering is not that high.
Lobsters have a very very tiny brain scientifically proven to be smaller than the size of a grasshopper. They also do not have a central nervous system. These two non-components in their physiological makeup make them less likely to experience pain or to recognize suffering.
What about the hiss or “scream” which lobsters make? The occasional leg thrash? This is simply steam or water being introduced between the shell and the lobster meat. Lobsters have no vocal cords and therefore cannot scream. While this certainly won’t end the questions there are some steps you can take to ensure that you limit any potential pain or suffering this creature might make as you prepare him for dinner.
1. Make sure the water is boiling hot.
2. Do not add more lobsters than can be adequately covered by the water without bringing down the temperature (I recommend cooking them one or two at a time until you have finished them all. Simply remove the cooked lobsters from the pot and hold them while you boil the remainder.)
3. Put the lobster in head first and hold it in the water with tongs.
4. Do not take the rubber bands off of the claws to avoid the lobster grabbing onto the side of the pot, the tongs, etc.
